He sat beside the old man in the darkness, the hole in the top of the teepee the only source of light. The old man, naked, sat there quietly watching the fire.
“What are we going to do?” John asked, but the old man said nothing, he just sat, watching the fire. John wanted the man to say something, wanted him to give a lecture about magic. John felt comfortable in lectures, felt that someone was in charge and knew that he was going somewhere, comfortably, a journey from one idea, a core set of accepted ideas within the culture to some cultural or intellectual outlier, shepherded carefully by the knowledgeable guide who had researched and plotted out their course. Here, there was none of that. John was pressed up against the raw edge of discomfort, disgust, he felt it hard to take deep breaths and not just because of the smoke. He was having a difficult time concentrating, focusing on anything, his brain was trying to take in all the information at one time. He did not like not knowing where they were going, he did not like not knowing what they were going to do. Doing his best to calm down and pretend that he was not in the middle of fucking nowhere with a complete stranger sitting naked and silent beside him about to take part in a ceremony that had no name or description. John did what he did in situations like this, he framed it as fodder for his novel or a story. He took another deep breath and closed his eyes, then opened them again.
He created a shaman, a real shaman, not this crazy old man beside him, naked and apparently dumb, but a skinny old man in animal skins with crazy hair and crazier eyes. They sat in a tent much like the one they were in now, but it was heavy with scented smoke and hung with animal bones. “What are we doing?” the main character asked. “What we are going to do,” said the old wise man of John’s creating, “does not have a name. It is the nameless act.” “A nameless magic?” asked John’s main character. “No, we do not even call it magic, for it has no name, and will not be named. Speech is a magic in and of itself. This, what we are about to do, is the power that gave us that magic, the power before speech, the light that came out of the darkness, that which gave us our soul and our understanding, our speech and the power to name, and with the power to name, the power to create! But, there is a flipside to that creation, giving something a name can also diminish it, give it a limit, create what it can and cannot be. This power that we are about to indulge in is beyond that, its is something that cannot be given a name, it does not exist within your net of words and will not be contained by any term or the craft of human speech.” John’s main character was awed by this speech, taken aback by the crazy old man’s instinctive understanding of semiotics.
Back in the real teepee, he heard the old man next to him grunt. It was only a grunt, an exhalation of air through the back of the man’s throat and through his nostrils, but John knew, immediately and certainly, that the old man had been listening to John’s thoughts the entire time, and that the magic that he’d created in his head did not meet with the old man’s approval.
“Well if you don’t like it, why don’t you tell me what I should believe instead?” said John angrily to the old man, embarrassed both that he’d been so easily read and that he’d been so wrong about something he wanted so badly to be right about.
The old man looked at John placidly, pointed to John, poking him hard in the chest with a blunt finger that annoyed John more than he thought it should have. Then the old man put both hands over his eyes keeping them covered for a moment, then removed them again, looking directly at John. There was no emotion in his eyes, just a clear-eyed observation. His gaze withheld nothing from John and in return John could withhold nothing from the gaze, and in that moment he realized just how much unconscious artifice he was accustomed to carrying around with him, how much dancing he did with the information he carried around, how many walls and mazes he had erected to keep people from knowing what it was he was thinking and feeling, and how accustomed he was to walking the labyrinths that other people erected for the exact same reason. He realized, looking into the open gaze of the naked, fat old man he realized how tired he was, how much energy this took to keep himself from the world around him, and to keep the world around him from himself. How often he chose to see what people wanted him to believe rather than admitting to himself what he knew to be true just by looking at a person. His brain tried and failed to launch into an academic observation of the social and personal selves, but something, some thing quick and dark shot the thought out of the air and it crumpled and fell like a crow crushed by a stone. John was left with nothing but himself and the gaze of the old man and without warning he began to cry.